A part of Watch Media

AMWatchSunday29 January 2023

  • Search
  • Log in
  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Latest
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
18/09/2017at 13:34

Danish pension funds join insourcing bandwagon

AP Pension is planning to manage a much larger proportion of its assets internally. If all goes well, CIO Ralf Magnussen is ready to take the next step, he says in an interview with AMWatch. ATP is also pulling back investment mandates form external managers.
Photo: PR
BY MICHAEL DUELUND

Both AP Pension and ATP see the wisdom in saving costs and gaining more control over their investments, and the two funds are now bringing part of their investments back inhouse for internal management.

Thus they join the current trend, along with Industriens Pension and Pensiondanmark, among others, of increasing staff in-house and taking back investment mandates from external managers.

At AP Pension, Morten Hemmingsen took office as head of fixed income  on Aug. 1, while Morten Cederholm has been appointed as of Dec. 1 as head of equities. With these two positions, AP Pension has established two new units under CIO Ralf Magnussen, who says that AP is planning to hire another two employees in the equity unit, making it a five-person team, and bringing the  staff count of the whole investment unit up to 15.

"What I want is for us to be close to our investments, and we want to be active participants. If we are to achieve that, we need to work more in depth with the different asset classes. But on the other hand, we don't want to grow so big that we can't keep a dialogue. We believe that we can improve our investment processes by taking at least part of our equities under internal management," he tells AMWatch.

Small Danish, large European pension fund

Presently, about 9 percent of AP Pension's equity portfolio is managed internally, while the remaining mandates lie with external managers. The plan is for the pension fund to manage 19 percent of the equity portfolio ultimo 2017, and by year-end 2018 to have one third of the equities under management in-house.

Especially global equities are going to be managed internally to a greater extent at AP Pension.

"Historically, we have had Danish and foreign bank equities under internal management, but everything else under external management. We can tell from the results that that worked out well. But global equities are one of the fields in which we have been considering if we could manage it internally to a greater extent, and we have concluded that we will do just that," says Ralf Magnussen.

He explains that while AP Pension in a Danish context is among the top 10 largest pension funds, the customer-owned pension fund is number 87 on a European scale if counting the assets from ISP, which AP manages.

"So we are not a small Danish pension fund, we are a large European pension fund, and we are attractive in terms of management. But maybe we also need to consider that we are so big that we should take more operations back for internal management," he says.

ATP goes the same way

Denmarks largest and Europe's fourth largest pension fund, ATP, is also planning to pull back investment mandates from external managers, according to CEO Christian Hyldahl at the press conference that was held in connection with the pension fund's interim report.

"We have two reasons for this. One is that we want more control of our investments in terms of risk management. We also want to know more about how we invest so that we can look at correlations for the whole portfolio instead of just placing a mandate," he said, continuing:

"There is also the aspect of expenses. It's one thing to give mandates to skilled managers, but they also need payment. We are continuously assessing our expenses for external management; if our net rate of return after expenses could be higher if we did these things ourselves.

ATP informs AMWatch that the use of external credit managers – including high yield credits – is what the pension fund has reduced significantly in favor of internal management. However, this doesn't mean that ATP is going to increase staff in the investment unit.

"In recent years, we have established a number of investment teams, each with critical mass in both public and private markets. So it's more internal reallocation of resources that we want. We are also, however, keeping close tab on the possible need for a staff upgrade in one of the supporting functions," writes Stephan Ghisler-Solvang, head of press at ATP in an e-mail to AMWatch.

Being able to move pieces is an advantage

These arguments for lower expenses and more risk control are the same from Ralf Magnussen at AP Pension. He talks about the business case where AP Pension can reduce its expenses for external managers by DKK 50 million by managing one third of the equities in-house.

"So even though we are currently building a team around Rasmus Cederholm, the business case is still very good. But it also requires that we substitute with something of high quality. That is why I am very careful to remember that we must build this slowly," Ralf Magnussen says.

But the lower expenses alone are not what has enticed AP Pension to pull management back in-house, the CIO maintains.

"The comparative advantage that you gain by moving the pieces around in-house is flexibility. You are not necessarily bound to one investment strategy. You can assume a top down view o do this, and you can control risk. We want to make use of the flexibility that this choice gives us," he says.

Could lead to more

 Despite the immediate goal of having one third of the equities under internal management by the end of 2018, Ralf Magnussen will not rule out the possibility that AP Pension could go even further.

"Let's say that this went really well. Then we might very well increase this weight. Now we have this goal for a start, because we want to see if it works out before we do anything drastic. But it is a requirement that we have a team. It would be unprofessional to put a single person to the task, because by comparison, if you choose externally, you can choose the world's best managers," he says.

He points out that there are large-scale operation advantages to managing global equities in-house, so when the equity team is settled, they will relatively easily be able to take on even more internally without needing drastic staff level increases.

Is there an experiment in increasing staff and waiting to see what happens?

"You could say that. But we could do something even more drastic, like deciding to manage two thirds in-house. We are not going to do that. If we are to do this, we have to do it with a certain amount of force. We have to build a team that is strong enough, and it has to be attractive to work with equities in AP Pension," says Ralf Magnussen.

"We are acquiring experience now, and then we will adjust our course in view of this experience. But we are working from a foundation of experience in the current equity management team. It will be measured just like the external managers. I believe it is very essential to set the requirements as high for your internal mandates as for the external," says Ralf Magnussen, CIO at AP Pension.

AP Pension hires new equities chief 

Denmark's Kirstein splits business, launching Spektrum

Danish, Norwegian pension funds target developing countries

"The AP Funds became my Hotel California..." 

 

English Edit: Marie Honoré

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay ahead of development by receiving our newsletter on the latest sector knowledge.

!
Newsletter terms

Front page now

Pension firms can play a significant role in steering companies into a more sustainable direction, says SPP and Storebrand Head of Sustainability, Johanna Lundgren Gestlöf. | Foto: Jonas Eng
AMNews

Two additional pension firms join the green club in Swedish sustainability rankings

Swedish unit-link insurance companies have undergone their annual sustainability assessment by insurance brokers, Söderberg & Partners. Several have moved up and down the rankings.
  • Alecta goes from amber to red in sustainability report
  • New sustainability report: Higher quality in fund offerings from Swedish unit-link insurance companies

For subscribers

Maunu Lehtimäki, CEO of Evli. | Foto: PR Evli.
AMWatch

Alternative sales grow and net flows start to stabilize at Finland's Evli

For subscribers

Speed is of the essence when launching new investment products, CFO Masih Yazdi says. | Foto: PR / SEB
Fund Management

SEB aims for speedy product launches to make up for huge AUM drop in 2022

For subscribers

Foto: Thomas Borberg/Ritzau Scanpix
Responsible Investing

Danes' equity holdings shrank by 9% in 2022

For subscribers

Foto: Shannon Stapleton/Reuters/Ritzau Scanpix
AMNews

Investors are missing earnings data after 2022 IPO collapse

For subscribers

Karl C. W. Mathisen fills position as head of equities at Folketrygdfondet on Feb. 1. | Photo: Folketrygdfondet
People

Folketrygdfondet finds new head of equities in own ranks

For subscribers

Further reading

Timo Löyttyniemi, CEO of the State Pension Fund of Finland (VER). | Foto: PR VER.
AMWatch

Finnish state pension fund looks at boosting private assets exposure

”Taking into account how large changes have been taking place in the world during the past three years, we have made surprisingly few adjustments within our portfolio,” says Timo Löyttyniemi, CEO of Finland’s EUR 21.3bn State Pension Fund. 

For subscribers

Jacob Schlawitz (left) is the CEO of Max Matthiessen. Mikael Tjäder (right) is the CEO of Fondab, which will soon become fully integrated with Max Matthiessen. | Foto: Max Matthiessen / PR - Fondab / PR
Fund Management

The core of Max Matthiessen's business "will always be insurance brokerage"

Max Matthiessen’s recent acquisition of Fondab will not be its last. The Swedish insurance and finance company aims to own more of the value chain, CEO Jacob Schlawitz tells AMWatch. 

For subscribers

Marlene Nørgaard Carolus has joined Formue as associated partner. | Foto: PR Formue.
AMNews

Norwegian wealth advisor to open Danish office

Formue, wealth consultant based in Norway, plans to open an office in Copenhagen, thereby gaining presence throughout Scandinavia.

For subscribers

Latest news

  • Two additional pension firms join the green club in Swedish sustainability rankings – 27 Jan
  • Investors are missing earnings data after 2022 IPO collapse – 27 Jan
  • Danes' equity holdings shrank by 9% in 2022 – 27 Jan
  • SEB aims for speedy product launches to make up for huge AUM drop in 2022 – 27 Jan
  • Alternative sales grow and net flows start to stabilize at Finland's Evli – 27 Jan
  • Folketrygdfondet finds new head of equities in own ranks – 27 Jan
  • Global clean-energy investments match fossil fuel for the first time – 27 Jan
  • Here is how Norwegian fund managers performed in 2022 – 26 Jan
  • Morgan Stanley fines its bankers over messaging breaches – 26 Jan
  • Slight recovery in SEB’s AUM in fourth quarter – but outflow continues – 26 Jan
See all

Jobs

  • Porteføljemanager til danske ejendomme i PenSam

  • PenSam søger en jurist med interesse for den finansielle sektor

Watch Jobs

  • Erfaren fuldmægtig eller advokat med interesse for danske og internationale virksomheder

  • Jurister søges til Corporate Legal i Danmarks Eksport & Investeringsfond

  • Centerdirektør til Sønderborg

  • Forvaltningsservicechef i Vestforbrænding

  • Business Change Manager til implementering af fremtidens togs uddannelsesprojekter

See all jobs

Jobs

  • Porteføljemanager til danske ejendomme i PenSam

  • PenSam søger en jurist med interesse for den finansielle sektor

See all jobs

Colophon

AMWatch
Search

Sections

  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
  • Sitemap
  • RSS feeds

Editor

Anne Louise Houmann

alh@amwatch.dk

Tel.: +45 2830 5142

Editor-in-chief

Anders Heering

Publisher

JP/Politiken Media Group Ltd

Advertising

annoncering@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Advertising

Job Advertising

job@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Jobs

Subscription

Try AMWatch or get an offer for a subscription meeting the exact needs of you or your company.

amwatch@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Learn more about subscriptions here

Address

AMWatch

Rådhuspladsen 37

1785 Copenhagen K, Denmark

Tel.: +45 3330 8382

Guidelines

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © AMWatch — All rights reserved

Microsoft is in the process of discontinuing Internet Explorer – and so are we.
For a better experience, we recommend using one of the following browsers.

Kind regards,
AMWatch

Google ChromeMozilla FirefoxMicrosoft Edge