Shah, 50, said he attempted to settle a Danish criminal investigation into his trading operations in 2018 by offering a payment of EUR 250m (USD 293.3m) to the country’s prosecutors. The confidential settlement would have encompassed a parallel civil case, and he said he wouldn’t have admitted any liability. But, according to Shah, authorities had other ideas.
"The response was: ‘admit all allegations, pay all of the money you received, tell us how the trading was done,’" Shah, who has been based in Dubai since 2009, said via email. "‘And, in return, we will give you a four-day trial in Denmark rather than four months and a really nice cell for your four-year sentence,"’ he said. "I obviously rejected that."
A spokesman for the Danish prosecutor service, known as SØIK, declined to comment.
Shah, a former trader at Rabobank Group and Credit Suisse Group AG who later set up his own fund, Solo Capital Partners LLP, is the subject of an array of legal activity across several jurisdictions as a result of his involvement in controversial trades that targeted dividend-tax laws.
Authorities are probing him in Denmark and Germany while mammoth civil cases in the U.K., Dubai and the U.S. are under way. Shah has denied any wrongdoing and hasn’t been charged.
In the U.K. civil case, the Danish Tax Agency, or Skat, alleges that Shah and Solo helped orchestrate a complex fraud that robbed the country of some DKK 12.7bn (USD 2bn) through illicit refunds on dividend tax. Shah received hundreds of millions of dollars as a result of the transactions. According to his defense, Solo helped clients engage in “lawful and legitimate trading strategies that were conducted at all times in accordance with Danish law.”
Shah said he may be open to trying again to settle, this time directly with Skat. “My lawyers have advised it is too early in the litigation to do so,” but there might come a “right time,” he said.
For its part, the agency said that while it has previously entered into settlements in other cases, it doesn’t initiate negotiations. Whether an agreement can be reached would depend on several factors, including the role of the defendant and how much in payment is offered.
The actions targeting Shah are part of a broader investigation across Europe into controversial dividend-tax transactions, which have since become known as Cum-Ex trades. Probes have so far ensnared hundreds of traders, bankers, hedge-fund managers and lawyers.