A part of Watch Media

AMWatchMonday6 February 2023

  • Search
  • Log in
  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Latest
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
14/08/2017at 13:19

CEO of ATP: We invest responsibly, but communicating about ESG is difficult

ATP, Denmark's compulsory occupational state pension, holds DKK 800 billion in assets. But although the contributions are mandatory, ATP is not required to take an ideological stand on investments. Returns still take priority, says the new CEO of ATP, Christian Hyldahl.
Photo: ATP PR FOTO
by LYKKE OGSTRUP LUNDE

"We must do things properly so our customers can rest assured that we will act responsibly," says Christian Hyldahl, the CEO of ATP, to the question of ATP being the forefront leader in morally sound investments. Hyldahl has been in charge of ATP since the beginning of 2017, and he is beginning to settle down in his top position. 

Hyldahl, who was formerly CEO of Nordea Asset Management, doesn't believe that ATP should compare itself with other pension funds.

"I hesitate to compare our sustainability to other pension companies. I measure it in terms of whether I believe we're doing enough," he explains, pointing out that if those compared to are doing a mediocre job or are working in a niche, the measurement will be inaccurate.

No self-imposed limits

ATP has no specific moral limits set for investments. The starting point is simply that as long as the company being invested in complies with laws and conventions in Denmark and/or ATP, the investment is fine. Thus ATP doesn’t leave anything out of consideration, and the company's investment opportunities span everything within the law. That means coal, oil, weapons, porn, and other controversial subjects that are generally disapproved of in present-day Denmark.

"Should we blacklist tobacco? Tobacco is legal. 30 percent of the Danish population smokes. I personally don't, but I don't think it's wrong to be involved with tobacco as long as the Danish Parliament hasn't outlawed tobacco and the smoking thereof in Denmark," says Hyldahl. He goes on to explain ATP's specific situation:

"We are very aware that we represent five million people with all the variation that brings. There are many opinions on the matter of what is right to do. If you take the most puritanical investors, then tobacco, alcohol, weapons, and such are out of the question.  It might not be what the Danish people and Parliament expect us to do. We have to stay more neutral in that matter."

On the other hand, ATP is a member of several fora that focus on responsible investing, active ownership, and corporate governance standards. ATP is also a signatory of UN PRI – the six UN principles for responsible investments – and the group supports the UN's Global Compact.

Risk assessment before ideology

ATP does not, according to own statements, have any investments in coal. However, this is not due to an ambition of reducing carbon emission, but simply that ATP has carried out a risk assessment of investment opportunities in coal, and found that the risk was too high.

"We exclude coal because there is a risk, not for ideological reasons. That approach can get you far," he says.

But you call it a risk assessment and not a political standpoint. ATP law has nothing to say about excluding investment opportunities for political or ideological reasons?

"No, that's right, it doesn't. And we have an ongoing dialogue with a lot of competent decision-makers. But we can, quite right, exclude things. And we do."

Yes, but you keep quiet about it…

"Actually, we have an exclusion list on equities." The list is available to the public on ATP’s website.

That's correct. But you are not actively saying, "We exclude coal, we exclude oil, we exclude weapons for ideological reasons…"

"No, we are not. We have more than 5 million members – some of them want to support sustainable energy and ban coal, others believe that nuclear power is the way to go, yet others believe that ATP should lend its support to Danish agriculture and support that sector with investments, and some think we should invest more in start-ups. I could keep going. One of the reasons for ATP's history of solid returns is that we have remained untouched by the political currents of time and have managed to invest independent of special interests. That was also clear from the object clause back when ATP was founded in 1964. So ATP's funds should not be invested according to ideological or political interests. But we do, of course, need to invest safely and responsibly."

With you many billions under management, can't ATP put its back into the cause and try to push others towards a world that uses less fossil fuels?

"We do. But that is not the same as not investing. We were put in this world to generate good returns for all five million customers, but we do have to do so responsibly. The returns are the ultimate goal, but returns and ESG are often linked. No matter if you are fueled by ideology or cold, hard numbers, ESG standards are always relevant," Hyldahl explains.

So you do work with them?

"One can always improve. But ATP has probably been the most visible active investor for many years. There has not exactly been a crowd fighting for time on the rostrum at general assemblies. ATP has always been there. I think that's some impressive commitment from ATP over the years,” Hyldahl points out.

DKK 200 billion investment portfolio

ATP's portfolio is distributed so that about DKK 650 billion (EUR 87.2 billion) pertains to the pension provider's hedging of return guarantees made to future pensioners. The hedging is made via Danish and German government bonds and interest rate swaps. This money goes to cover the interest rate risk on ATP's pension obligations.

In addition, there is a bonus potential of about DKK 100 billion plus liquidity from hedging, so Hyldahl's rough estimate of the investment portfolio's size is about DKK 200 billion.

About DKK 40 billion is invested in Danish and international equities. The rest of the portfolio is property bonds, real estate, infrastructure, private equity, government bonds (including emerging markets), credit, and derivatives, including interest rate derivatives, equity- and commodities futures, and inflation swaps.

Older illiquid investments are not up to ESG standards

Not all of ATP's portfolio is screened on ESG principles, and several derivatives go under the radar. Older illiquid investments in the portfolio have not been ESG screened. There is, however, inherently not much to do about it, as the investments will naturally come to an end. But new illiquid investments are made in cooperation with the ESG team:

"The illiquid part of the portfolio is the least mature in terms of ESG discipline. But our ESG screening process is very thorough. Even before we invest, the ESG team is working with the Direct Investment team," Hyldahl explains. He assesses that ATP well up to pace compared to the rest of the industry in terms of being a responsible investor.

"The illiquid universe is not as systematized as the listed universe, and we are not as far ahead in illiquid investments as we are in their liquid counterparts. But we are going to make higher demands to illiquid investments over time," says Hyldahl. ATP does not presently have a stated objective for private equity.

"No, at this time we don't. But when we have an objective, we will come back and make and make a public announcement. I think you will find that with every half-year passing, we become increasingly clear on these points."

Lack of standards is a serious problem

Hyldahl, who is a member of the Danish Committee on Corporate Governance Recommendations, would like more standards in the field. The presently governing rules make it difficult to gauge whether an investment has any effect. The buzzword "impact" comes up:

"There's a big problem with gathering data and having shared standards. How do you make it measurable and investable? I think it's important that everybody gets better means of measuring impact. But many companies don't provide very detailed reports on this. We would like that to improve," says Hyldahl, touching on a sensitive subject in the ESG debate. It is difficult to compare companies and industries and ethics, and ESG screenings can sometimes feel a bit loosely defined. Like selling rubber bands by length. For this reason, it is also difficult to judge exactly who does right and who does wrong.

ATP is not clear enough about ESG measures

Coincidentally, reporting and transparency, or the lack thereof, is exactly what several NGOs have criticized ATP for. ATP was placed last in a 2016 ranking made by WWF, and in Spring 2017, ATP was placed last again in an Asset Owner Disclosure projects survey.

Hyldahl emphasizes several times during the interview that in his seven months in office, he has been more preoccupied with acting responsibly than with reporting of responsibility.

"I'm aware that we are the major investor, we have all our funds gathered here, an thus is attracts a lot of interest, and I respect that 100 percent. But I really don't think we're that much worse at communicating about ESG than everybody else. Someone else might be better at telling stories. But in the end, I don't think we act so differently from the rest. I don't believe we're lagging behind the rest of the industry, if that's what you're hinting at?"

Yes, that's what I'm hinting at.

"I don't think we are. I haven't worked for any other pension funds, but it's safe to say that we have the biggest ESG team in the Danish pension industry. It's six people."

Communication can improve very soon

ATP has gradually taken the hint from the NGOs that when they keep inquiring for transparency, it would be wise to take another look at the company's communication about ESG.

Those interested will thus soon find that ATP's communication improves in clarity and frequency.

"Communicating is difficult, and only a niche part of our costumers who have any interest in this. But we want to communicate about it. And I think we are getting better at it, slowly but surely," says Hyldahl. He will not give a time estimate of ATP's resolution of the communication problem:

"I'm not getting any more specific. I would rather that you look at our interim report and compare it to the previous one in terms of communication. I think you will find that it contains more information than both last year's interim reports and the full-year results. But it's difficult. We don't want any misunderstandings. We don't want exaggerated expectations, because not everyone is fully familiar with these concepts. It's so tiring when people clearly don't understand," Hyldahl says.

But doesn't it count that you gain an educational influence the more you communicate and explain, the more people understand what you're doing and why you do it?

"Improving our communication skills is definitely an item on my agenda," Hyldahl concludes.

English Edit: Marie Honoré

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay ahead of development by receiving our newsletter on the latest sector knowledge.

!
Newsletter terms

Front page now

Chief Risk Officer of ATP Kim Kehlet Johansen | Foto: PR/ATP
Pension

ATP rejects new criticism of its investment model

The Danish state pension fund must undergo a complete transformation, conclude Copenhagen Business School professor Jesper Rangvid and associate professor Henrik Ramlau-Hansen in a new analysis.
  • Pension giant turns back on real estate and infrastructure, favoring bonds instead
  • Pension funds aspire to cut carbon emissions by 23 times that of Denmark's population 

For subscribers

Head of Nordea Asset & Wealth Management Storre Snorset. PR / NORDEA
Fund Management

Wholesale and institutional sales dampened Nordea’s AUM recovery in Q4  

For subscribers

Ukrainian refugees currently reside on the premises, but the property used to lay grounds to domestic company Haldor Topsøe. | Foto: PR
AMWatch

Denmark's Sampension invests in temporary refugee housing

Fredrik Nordström, CEO of the Swedish Investment Fund Association, believes that unclear EU regulation plays a significant role in the decisions of fund managers to reclassify their Article 9 funds. | Foto: Karl Gabor
Fund Management

AUM in Swedish Article 9 funds halved in Q4 – EU regulation partly to blame

For subscribers

Head of Danske Bank Asset Management Christian Heiberg says he is in a much better mood today than he was just six months ago. | Foto: Pr / Dbam
AMWatch

Danske's outflow continued in Q4 due to loss of flagship team

For subscribers

Ilmarinen's Deputy CEO Mikko Mursula. | Foto: PR Ilmarinen.
AMNews

Ilmarinen changes benchmarks to become carbon neutral in 2035

For subscribers

Further reading

Speed is of the essence when launching new investment products, CFO Masih Yazdi says. | Photo: PR / SEB
Fund Management

SEB aims for speedy product launches to make up for huge AUM drop in 2022

The loss of a SEK 50bn mandate affected SEB’s AUM performance last year. Looking ahead, CFO Masih Yazdi believes that alternatives and fixed income will be important investment areas.

For subscribers

Head of Danske Bank Asset Management Christian Heiberg says he is in a much better mood today than he was just six months ago. | Foto: Pr / Dbam
AMWatch

Danske's outflow continued in Q4 due to loss of flagship team

The departure of a highly regarded Emerging Markets Debt-team made Danske’s comeback in Q4 harder than expected. Head of Asset Management Christian Heiberg now says he underestimated the influence of the team.

For subscribers

Foto: PR/TDC
AMNews

CIP partner moves on to new challenges

Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners (CIP) COO and partner leaves the company to pursue opportunities elsewhere. He will stay on as advisor.

For subscribers

Latest news

  • Denmark's Sampension invests in temporary refugee housing – 3 Feb
  • ATP rejects new criticism of its investment model – 3 Feb
  • AUM in Swedish Article 9 funds halved in Q4 – EU regulation partly to blame – 3 Feb
  • Danske's outflow continued in Q4 due to loss of flagship team – 3 Feb
  • Ilmarinen changes benchmarks to become carbon neutral in 2035 – 3 Feb
  • Wholesale and institutional sales dampened Nordea’s AUM recovery in Q4 – 3 Feb
  • Norway set to tap its oil wealth to finance war aid for Ukraine – 2 Feb
  • Investors are skeptical of companies' sustainability storytelling: "It takes more than just a good story" – 2 Feb
  • Norway's oil fund will vote out board members from firms lacking climate goals – 2 Feb
  • CapMan promotes new leading duo from its own ranks to oversee ambitious growth plan – 2 Feb
See all

Jobs

  • PenSam søger en jurist med interesse for den finansielle sektor

  • Porteføljemanager til danske ejendomme i PenSam

Watch Jobs

  • Jurister søges til Corporate Legal i Danmarks Eksport & Investeringsfond

  • Salesforce-udvikler eller -arkitekt

  • Erfaren IT Supporter

  • Forvaltningsservicechef i Vestforbrænding

  • Business Intelligence Specialist

See all jobs

Jobs

  • PenSam søger en jurist med interesse for den finansielle sektor

  • Porteføljemanager til danske ejendomme i PenSam

See all jobs

Colophon

AMWatch
Search

Sections

  • Fund Management
  • Pension
  • Responsible Investing
  • People
  • Sitemap
  • RSS feeds

Editor

Anne Louise Houmann

alh@amwatch.dk

Tel.: +45 2830 5142

Editor-in-chief

Anders Heering

Publisher

JP/Politiken Media Group Ltd

Advertising

annoncering@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Advertising

Job Advertising

job@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Jobs

Subscription

Try AMWatch or get an offer for a subscription meeting the exact needs of you or your company.

amwatch@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7491

Learn more about subscriptions here

Address

AMWatch

Rådhuspladsen 37

1785 Copenhagen K, Denmark

Tel.: +45 3330 8382

Guidelines

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © AMWatch — All rights reserved

Microsoft is in the process of discontinuing Internet Explorer – and so are we.
For a better experience, we recommend using one of the following browsers.

Kind regards,
AMWatch

Google ChromeMozilla FirefoxMicrosoft Edge